6 Butterhead Lettuce Substitutes that Taste Great

Do you have a recipe that calls for Butterhead lettuce and you can’t seem to find any? Or maybe you’re just looking for a fresh idea on an old meal. Either way we can help you out as we go through our favorite butterhead lettuce substitutes.

Butterhead lettuce, also known as Boston or Bibb lettuce, is a delicate and tasty leafy green that is commonly used in salads and sandwiches. Its soft, tender leaves and mild flavor make it a popular choice for those who prefer a more subtle taste in their greens.

Butterhead Lettuce Substitutes

However, there are times when butterhead lettuce may not be readily available, or you may be looking for a change in your greens game. In this post, we will break down the top substitutes for butterhead lettuce, so you can continue to enjoy your salads and sandwiches even when your preferred greens are not in season.

1. Iceberg Lettuce

Iceberg lettuce is one of the most common lettuce substitutes for butterhead. Its crisp and crunchy texture makes it a popular choice for salads and sandwiches, and its mild flavor complements a variety of toppings.

Iceberg Lettuce

Iceberg lettuce is also a great source of hydration, which makes it a great option for summer salads. However, it is important to note that iceberg lettuce has less nutritional value than butterhead lettuce, so it may not be the best option if you’re looking for a healthier substitute.

2. Romaine Lettuce

Romaine lettuce is another popular substitute for butterhead lettuce. It has a slightly more robust flavor than butterhead lettuce, but its crisp texture makes it a great option for salads and sandwiches.

Romaine Lettuce

Romaine lettuce is also a great source of vitamins A, C, and K, as well as fiber and potassium. One of the benefits of using romaine lettuce as a substitute for butterhead lettuce is that it holds up well when dressed, so it won’t wilt or get soggy like some other greens.

3. Green Leaf Lettuce

Green leaf lettuce is another popular substitute for butterhead lettuce. Its mild flavor and tender leaves make it a great choice for those who prefer a subtler taste in their greens. Green leaf lettuce is also a great source of vitamins A and K, as well as fiber and potassium.

Unlike iceberg lettuce, green leaf lettuce has a higher nutritional value, making it a healthier option. Additionally, its delicate texture makes it a great choice for adding to sandwiches or wrapping around fillings for a fresh, crunchy bite.

4. Red Leaf Lettuce

Red leaf lettuce is another great substitute for butterhead lettuce, and it is a popular choice for those who are looking for a little extra color in their salads. Its tender leaves and mild flavor make it a great choice for those who prefer a subtler taste, and its high nutritional value makes it a healthier option.

Red Leaf Lettuce

Red leaf lettuce is also a great source of vitamins A and K, as well as fiber and potassium. Additionally, its bright color makes it a great option for adding some visual interest to your salads and sandwiches.

5. Arugula

Arugula is a spicy, nutty green that is a popular substitute for butterhead lettuce. Its bold flavor and tender leaves make it a great choice for those who are looking to add a little extra oomph to their salads and sandwiches.

arugula

Arugula is also a great source of vitamins A and K, as well as fiber and potassium. However, its bold flavor can be overwhelming for some, so it is important to pair it with milder ingredients to balance out the taste.

6. Radicchio

Radicchio is a bitter, slightly spicy green that is a great substitute for butterhead lettuce. Its bitter flavor and crunchy texture make it a great choice for those who are looking for a change from the typical mild greens.

Radicchio

Radicchio is also a great source of vitamins A and K, as well as fiber and potassium. However, its bold flavor can be overwhelming for some, so it is a good idea to use it sparingly your first time.


There’s so many delicious and nutritious substitutes for butterhead lettuce that you can use in your recipes. Whether you prefer the crunchy texture of iceberg lettuce or the mild flavor of Boston lettuce, there is sure to be a substitute that you will enjoy.

So next time you’re in a pinch, try one of these substitutes for butterhead lettuce and see for yourself!

About Rachelle

Hi, I'm Rachel! I love cooking and finding new recipes but was always missing one of the ingredients in my kitchen. I created Can I Substitute? for people like me who are one substitute away from a great meal. If you're looking for great ingredient substitutes you've come to the right place. Feel free to contact me with any questions or comments.